(disagreement with premise 5.)

I disagree that if what is worthwhile for anyone is promoted, that may involve benefit, but at the very least, respecting what is worthwhile for anyone involves not subjecting that person to avoidable harm.


A. I do not find benefits to be worthwhile.

Refutation

B. I do not find it unworthwhile when others avoidably harm me.

Refutation

RETURN TO MAIN ARGUMENT

HOME