(disagreement with premise 3.)

I disagree that the second-best way to uphold what is worthwhile is to salvage the greatest possible disjunction of what is worthwhile for persons.


A. There is no need for second-best. With a bit of creativity, we can always uphold what is worthwhile for the conjunction of all persons!

Refutation

B. The second-best way is rather to uphold a lesser disjunction of what is worthwhile for persons.

Refutation

RETURN TO MAIN ARGUMENT

HOME